Calvary's Father James is a good priest who is faced with sinister and troubling circumstances brought about by a mysterious member of his parish. Although he continues to comfort his own fragile daughter and reach out to help members of his church with their various scurrilous moral, and often comic, problems, he feels sinister and troubling forces closing in, and begins to wonder if he will have the courage to face his own personal Calvary.

Back in high school, original mean girl Amanda Vaughn mercilessly tormented her less attractive classmates. Twenty years later, after her hubby is busted for a Ponzi scheme, and meets his maker in a particularly scandalous way, a disgraced Amanda is back to start life anew under her mother's palatial roof. But will the good women of her hometown welcome her with open arms or dole out some kick-ass karmic payback? Let's just say, hell hath no fury...